If you’re wondering whether a bidet attachment or a bidet toilet seat is better for you, it’s essential to first understand your specific needs and which of the two can fulfill them best.”
A bidet attachment is a bathroom fixture that is installed between your toilet seat and the existing toilet bowl.
Meanwhile, a bidet seat is a plumbing fixture that is placed on top of your toilet, replacing the current toilet seat entirely.
Both bidet attachments and bidet seats offer their own advantages and disadvantages, so let’s explore these in depth to help you determine which option is the right fit for you.
Comparison: Bidet Attachment vs. Bidet Seat
| Feature | Bidet Attachment | Bidet Seat |
| Self-cleaning Nozzle | Yes | Yes |
| Adjustable Nozzle | Optional | √ |
| Warm Water | Optional | √ |
| Air Dryer | × | √ |
| Heated Seat | × | √ |
| Toilet Paper Needed | Few Sheets | No |
| Electric/Non-electric | Non-electric | Electric |
| Price | Low | High |
Price
The price of a bidet seat can vary widely, depending on the features, design, and brand. Bidet seats typically range in cost from $200 to over $1,000.
In comparison, a bidet attachment is much more affordable. The price for bidet attachments generally falls between $20 and $100+, depending on the functionality, design, and brand.
Function
Bidet attachments provide the essential washing and self-cleaning features. These basic functionalities are sufficient for many users.
Bidet seats, however, go beyond these basic features. They often come equipped with advanced options, including water temperature control, memory settings, seat heating, and even warm air drying.
Operation
One of the main advantages of a bidet attachment is that it does not require electricity or batteries to operate. You simply turn or press a knob to activate the washing function. This makes it simple and easy for anyone to use.
In contrast, a bidet seat requires a connection to a power source. It often has a control panel on one side or a remote control with multiple buttons. While these options offer more functionality, they can make operations more complex, particularly for elderly individuals or children.
If operated incorrectly, it may fail to perform functions such as water spraying, heating, or deodorizing. In some cases, improper use may even cause a malfunction in the electrical components of the product.
Toilet Fit
A bidet attachment is highly versatile and can be installed easily on over 95% of toilet models.
While the bidet seat is designed with intelligence, comfort, and technology in mind, it may not fit every toilet. There are specific restrictions on the size of the toilet and the distance between the water tank and the front of the seat, as well as the distance between the installation holes. If your toilet falls outside the acceptable range, installing a bidet seat may not be possible.
Maintenance and Replacement Cost
The cost of maintaining a bidet attachment is minimal. In the event that the attachment wears out, it is inexpensive to replace with a new one.
In contrast, the bidet seat, being an electrical product, contains advanced internal motors and integrated circuits. If a malfunction occurs and key components need to be replaced, the cost of maintenance and repairs can be quite high.
Here are a few of the best Bidet Attachments
Bidet Neo 120 Attachment Review After 2 Month Use
I installed the Neo 120 bidet attachment on my American Standard low flush toilet, which already had an elongated seat. The quality of the Neo 120 is fantastic. The plastic is rigid and doesn’t feel cheap at all, and the supplied metal braided hoses are of high quality. The ceramic valves inside the unit work perfectly and seem much more reliable than traditional rubber seals or O-rings.
I purchased the less common white model, and the design is sleek and clean. While the bidet did stand out a bit on my toilet for the first couple of weeks, especially with the metal hose being quite visible, I’ve gotten used to it after two months and hardly notice it now.
Overall, I’m really pleased with the Neo 120. It’s well-made, easy to install, and has been working flawlessly since I set it up. If you’re looking for a reliable bidet attachment that’s simple to install and blends well with most bathroom setups, I’d highly recommend this one. The shut-off valve is also a great optional add-on for those who want extra control over their water flow.
Now I’ll review the actual use of this bidet (after using it for at least 2 months).
Here is my actual thoughts after using this attachment for 2 months.
After using the Neo 120 for two months, I can confidently say that this attachment has completely transformed my bathroom experience. First and foremost, the dread of going to the bathroom is a thing of the past. I now feel cleaner and more refreshed than I ever did with toilet paper. In fact, using toilet paper feels outdated and ineffective, like trying to clean something sticky with a dry cloth instead of water. My use of TP has drastically reduced, and I now find myself frustrated when I have to use it elsewhere.
One of my initial concerns was the cold water, but honestly, it’s not an issue. The cool water is actually refreshing, and I love how simple the Neo 120 is without needing any complex electrical or hot water hookups. Even in the mornings, the cooler water hasn’t bothered me, and I don’t foresee any issues in the winter.
Some people have mentioned that the water pressure is too strong, but I haven’t had any trouble adjusting it to a comfortable level. The bidet has enough force to clean thoroughly, and with the right control on the knob, you can easily manage the pressure.
For those who need less pressure, using the self-cleaning function first helps reduce the initial force, and there’s always the option to install a water shut-off valve for even more control, though I haven’t found the need for it.
Speaking of the self-cleaning feature, it’s a nice touch. I haven’t had any issues with the nozzle getting dirty, but it’s good to know that it’s there when I need it. The extra cleaning of the toilet bowl using this function is a bonus, although you do need to be slightly more careful cleaning around the nozzle cover with a brush.
One thing I didn’t expect is how much cleaner my toilet stays. After each use, I simply wipe down any water that may have splashed on the rim or under the seat, which keeps everything spotless. This water is clean overspray, not dirty at all. Depending on your movements, sometimes there’s none at all, but on the rare occasions there is, it’s easy to handle.
As for drying off, I usually pat dry with a small amount of TP, but for more thorough drying, I use a small towel, which is just as easy. The comfort of knowing you’re really clean after each use is unbeatable. I’ve had no more irritation, soreness, or any discomfort – just pure cleanliness.
Finally, I discovered something unexpected: on the highest pressure setting, you can give yourself a gentle enema. It’s a bit of a hidden feature, but if you’re open to experimenting, it can help you avoid extra trips to the bathroom, especially after a difficult bowel movement. It’s surprisingly effective, and I find it really helpful when needed.
Overall, I’m incredibly happy with the Neo 120. It’s time for the U.S. to catch up with the rest of the world and embrace bidets. This device is simple, effective, and a total game-changer for hygiene. Toilet paper alone just doesn’t cut it anymore!
Conclusion
If you’re looking for an affordable bidet with basic functions, a bidet attachment is an excellent choice that provides essential features without breaking the bank.
On the other hand, if you desire more advanced features and a more luxurious bathroom experience, and the higher cost is within your budget, then the bidet seat may be the better option for you.